Barbara Stanwyck Blogathon: Double Indemnity


Barbara Stanwyck: Double Indemnity 

Some actors are born to play a certain type. The word type-cast does exist for a reason.  Some are gruff and cast as cops, while others are wise and cast as grandfathers. This, however, was not the case for Barbara Stanwyck‘s Phyllis Dietrichson when cast in Double Indemnity.

Double Indemnity,  (1944, Billy Wilder director)

Although she had played characters with a severe moral deficiency in the past, before Double Indemnity Stanwyck had yet to play an all out, conscious free, cold-blooded killer – let alone one draped in femme fatale’s clothing. Yes, at first glance Barbara Stanwyck seems a bit miscast as the woman whose charm and beauty are to bring a noble man to his untimely doom. Sure, we’ve seen her sleep her way to the top in Baby Face and flirt like her life depended on it in Ball of Fire but never had Stanwyck been deemed the cool seductress or breaker of man. And to her credit, that’s not how she played the role. Her femme fatale is so much more.

Barbara Stanwyck as Phyllis in Double Indemnity (1944, Billy Wilder director)

The typical femme fatale up to this point had made use of one primary weapon: an ungodly beauty with innate feminine charms. Sure, they were intelligent, plotting creatures, I am in no way saying the femme fatale is only beauty, but it was always their beauty they utilized first. With Stanwyck, beauty but one of the many tools in her arsenal. With Stanwyck, the femme fatale is less seduction and more manipulation. Every conversation is an opportunity to consume information or  feed lies with every word calculated to elicit the correct emotional response. She can see the evil in the hearts of men, allowing herself to become a reflection of their own greed and naked ambition. Yes, insurance salesman Walter Neff (Fred MacMurray) may have already fantasized about committing the perfect crime but without Stanwyck’s cold manipulation, without her false charms, it would have remained just that – harmless fantasy. Although Neff clearly had a dark side, it would never have seen light of day if not for Phyllis Dietrichson.

Barbara Stanwyck and Fred MacMurray in Double Indemnity (1944, Billy Wilder director)

For me, the most riveting part of Stanwyck’s performance is during the killing of her husband, only known as Mr. Dietrichson. The choice of Billy Wilder to remain close on Stanwyck’s face as opposed to showing the actual murder was genius. Her face is a culmination of everything that has transpired. Her initial surprise, the surprise that this is actually happending, is short lived. What happens next is powerful. All at once we see in her face the naked ambition and greed that drives her. Although her face is restrained, it does not lessen her ugly satisfaction at her husband’s unnatural death, at  her undeserved reward.

Barbara Stanwyck in Double Indemnity (1944, Billy Wilder director)

Phyllis Dietrichson could have easily been your typical seductress, a femme fatale shrouded in beauty and mystery whose only saving grace is her love for her “victim”. Instead, we got something different. We got something colder, more calculating. What we got was a murderer disguised a seductress, a women with love for only herself, her ambition and her greed. What we got was one of Barbara Stanwyck’s best performances of her career.


This post was written in conjunction with the Barbara Stanwyck Blogathon hosted by The Girl with the White Parasol.  There are so many more wonderful Classic Bloggers participating in this event so please be sure to check out the other entries.


Minoo Allen for Classic Movie Hub

Visit CMH’s BlogHub for more posts about Barbara Stanwyck by Veteran and Emerging Classic Movie Bloggers. 

This entry was posted in Blogathons, Posts by Minoo Allen and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Barbara Stanwyck Blogathon: Double Indemnity

  1. Aubyn Eli says:

    I can’t be casual and offhand about Double Indemnity since it’s not only one of my favorite movies of all time, it’s also one of the movies that first turned me on to classic film. My kid self had just never seen anything like it. Everything, the blonde wig, the stoic MacMurray narration, the cigarette-lighting, the dust floating in through the blinds is just burned into my memory.

    I really like that you emphasize how it’s not just Stanwyck’s beauty that’s the main allure. The cold calculating mind is just as much an attraction to Neff as the ankles. Personally, I always suspect that it’s the idea of the crime that really seduces Neff more than Phyllis herself, potent as her charms are. He wants the woman but he’s fascinated by the idea of committing murder for her. Phyllis on the other hand, is endlessly interesting to me because she seems so utterly heartless, so devoid of pity or human understanding. Until that final ambiguous moment when she can’t take the last shot. Sort of reminiscent of Lady Macbeth.

    I’m so happy that someone chose to write about Double Indemnity, one of the crowning jewels in Stanwyck’s crown, and I’m so happy that person was you. You’ve been a great supporter to this blogathon and I thank you from the bottom of my heart.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.