The Romantic-Comedy Blogathon: The Thin Man’s Perfect Marriage

The Romantic-Comedy Blogathon: The Thin Man’s Perfect Marriage

An inventor goes missing and his young mistress is found dead. Just like that, a murder and mystery become our entrance into the world of the The Thin Man. Yet, we soon find out that the murder and mystery aspect of this murder mystery film are secondary in the film’s overall relevance. Sure, crime may provide the film’s surface story, but it’s the characters, specifically lead characters of sleuthing spouses Nick and Nora Charles, that gives the film its substance. Rather than a dark and cerebral case of who-done-it-and-why, the film adopted a tone and style more on par with a comedy of manners or screwball comedy than a of hard-boiled crime-thriller. The murder, you see, is only a means to get to the end of the film. The relationship and marriage of Nick and Nora is everything that comes in-between.

The Thin Man

Myrna Loy and William Powell as Hollywood’s Best married couple, Nick and Nora Charles in The Thin Man (1934, W.S Van Dyke Director)

It’s all but impossible to think of anyone other than Myrna Loy and William Powell as the eternally drunk detecting duo. Their white-hot chemistry was so strong and magnetic it was hard for many to believe they were not married in IRL (or in real life for those a little less dedicated to the internet than me). However, the two were not always a shoe-in for the role. After working with both actors on the film Manhattan Melodrama, director W.S Van Dyke knew who he wanted the two to play the leads in his upcoming adaptation of the Dashiell Hammett novel, The Thin Man. Loy and Powell had struck up a quick friendship, developing a humorous and charming rapport with each other. Their light repartee was noticed by Van Dyke who knew that was exactly the whimsical interaction needed for Nick and Nora. Although the studio was initially reluctant to put two then-dramatic actors in such comical roles, the film’s minuscule budget and short shooting schedule, between 12-18 days depending on your source, convinced MGM to cast them. Soon after, Van Dyke had the screenplay altered to place more emphasis on their marital banter and less on the murder.

The result was nothing less than magical. Van Dyke’s carefree direction, coupled with a razor sharp script and the Loy/Powell dynamic, birthed not only a franchise that would last six more films, but also an entirely new paradigm of the silver screen marriage. Before The Thin Man most onscreen marriages were either miserable or conventionally idyllic. They either functioned as a plot point for the domestically unhappy, focusing on problems of infidelity and finance or simply functioned to show the proud patriarch and matriarch of a typical middle class family – a middle aged mother and father with little personality outside their immediate familial situations. Nick and Nora, however, broke that mold and created a new one in the shape of a martini glass.

nick-and-nora-drinkNick and Nora with their best friends: Gin and Tonic.

Relatively young, good-looking, and wealthy, Nick and Nora created a new category for on-screen marriage. Unlike the wretched marriages of melodramatic women’s pictures, they completely enjoyed one another’s presence and were often amused by quirks and nuances of each other’s personalities. And unlike the conventional marriages of, say, the Andy Hardy series, they had no children or societal burdens keeping them saddled down in one area. In effect, they were one of the screen’s first truly cosmopolitan marriages; a marriage partly built on the consumption of Cosmopolitans. Yes, the alcohol is as much a part of the marriage as the couple is, but that isn’t a bad thing. The drinks simply function as another act that binds the two together, a lubricant for their quick tongues and witty dialog. It is at once the surface activity and practiced ritual but never seen as an all-consuming vice.

Between their banter, their witticisms, and their ever-corroding livers, the marriage of Nick and Nora Charles is The Thin Man. Although the story may have a couple of murders and a disappearance in there, is anyone really watching for the mystery? No, we are watching it for the romance, we are watching it for the comedy, and we are watching it for Nick and Nora Charles.


A big Thank You to Lara (@backlotsfilm) of Backlots and Vince of Carole & Co. for hosting this fun Romantic Comedy Blogathon event! There are so many more wonderful Classic Bloggers participating in this event so please be sure to check out the other entries.

Minoo Allen for Classic Movie Hub

This entry was posted in Blogathons, Posts by Minoo Allen and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to The Romantic-Comedy Blogathon: The Thin Man’s Perfect Marriage

  1. Pingback: The Romantic Comedy Blogathon–DAY 2 ENTRIES | Backlots

  2. Nick and Nora are our really snazzy best friends. We love to hang out with them, but sometimes they’re awfully hard to keep up with. The way they joke with each other says “real love” to me.

  3. Leah says:

    Great line: “Nick and Nora, however, broke that mold and created a new one in the shape of a martini glass.” Enjoyable review–so true that the mystery is secondary–if it even ranks that high:)

  4. Leah says:

    Great line: “Nick and Nora, however, broke that mold and created a new one in the shape of a martini glass.” Enjoyable review. So true that the mystery is secondary–if it even ranks that high:)

  5. I like to blame Nick and Nora for my G&T preference 😉 Although The Thin Man is clearly a romance, I think I had always overlooked it as a romantic comedy, for me it’s always overshadowed by the ‘mystery’. So thanks for encouraging me to look at one of my faves in a new light!

  6. So true! We definitely are NOT watching the movie for mystery – all eyes are on Nick and Nora and their playful banter.

  7. Kristina says:

    Agreed, Nick & Nora are the ultimate “best friends” couple in my book, the fun duo you’d want to hang out with, great choice

  8. Pingback: Romantic comedy redux: A look back at the blogathon | Carole & Co.

  9. Cameron says:

    Great review! I love The Thin Man series–Loy and Powell are magic together! It’s easy to see why this film spawned five sequels!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.