| 1 . | The Black Swan (1942) | Tyrone Power, Maureen O'Hara, Laird Cregar, Thomas Mitchell | score |
| 2 . | Captain Blood (1935) | Errol Flynn, Olivia de Havilland, Lionel Atwill, Basil Rathbone | score |
| 3 . | Abbott and Costello Meet Captain Kidd (1952) | Bud Abbott, Lou Costello, Charles Laughton, Hillary Brooke | score |
| 4 . | The Pirate (1948) | Judy Garland, Gene Kelly, Walter Slezak, Gladys Cooper | score |
| 5 . | Blackbeard the Pirate (1952) | Robert Newton, Linda Darnell, William Bendix, Keith Andes | score |
| 6 . | Blackbeard's Ghost (1968) | Peter Ustinov, Dean Jones, Suzanne Pleshette, Elsa Lanchester | score |
| 7 . | The Sea Hawk (1940) | Errol Flynn, Brenda Marshall, Claude Rains, Donald Crisp | score |
| 8 . | The Sea Hawk (1924) | Milton Sills, Enid Bennett, Lloyd Hughes, Wallace Beery | score |
| 9 . | The Spanish Main (1945) | Paul Henreid, Maureen O'Hara, Walter Slezak, Binnie Barnes | score |
| 10 . | Treasure Island (1950) (1950) | Bobby Driscoll, Robert Newton, Basil Sydney, Walter Fitzgerald | score |
| 11 . | Peter Pan (1953) | Bobby Driscoll, Kathryn Beaumont, Hans Conried, Bill Thompson | score |
| 12 . | Captain Kidd (1945) | Charles Laughton, Randolph Scott, Barbara Britton, John Carradine | score |
| 13 . | Morgan, the Pirate (1961) | Steve Reeves, Ivo Garrani, Lidia Alfonsi, Giulio Bosetti | score |
| 14 . | The Master of Ballantrae (1953) | Errol Flynn, Roger Livesey, Anthony Steel, Beatrice Campbell | score |
| 15 . | The Black Pirate (1926) | Douglas Fairbanks, Billie Dove, Anders Randolf, Donald Crisp | score |
| 16 . | Peter Pan (1924) | Esther Ralston, Cyril Chadwick, Mary Brian, Jack Murphy | score |
| 17 . | The Crimson Pirate (1952) | Burt Lancaster, Nick Cravat, Eva Bartok, Torin Thatcher | score |
| 18 . | Pirates of Monterey (1947) | Maria Montez, Rod Cameron, Mikhail Rasumny, Phillip Reed | score |
| 19 . | The Princess and the Pirate (1944) | Bob Hope, Virginia Mayo, Walter Brennan, Walter Slezak | score |
| 20 . | Treasure Island (1934) | Wallace Beery, Jackie Cooper, Lionel Barrymore, Otto Kruger | score |
| 21 . | Captain Pirate (1952) | Louis Hayward, Patricia Medina, John Sutton, Charles Irwin | score |
| 22 . | Kidnapped (1960) | Peter Finch, James MacArthur, Bernard Lee, John Laurie | score |
| 23 . | Daphne and the Pirate (1916) | Lillian Gish, Elliott Dexter, Walter Long, Lucille Young | score |
| 24 . | Dancing Pirate (1936) | Frank Morgan, Steffi Duna, Luis Alberni, Victor Varconi | score |
| 25 . | A Submarine Pirate (1915) | Syd Chaplin, Wesley Ruggles, Glen Cavender, Phyllis Allen | score |
| 26 . | The Sky Pirate (1914) | Roscoe 'Fatty' Arbuckle, Minta Durfee, Hank Mann, Mabel Normand | score |
| 27 . | Such a Little Pirate (1918) | Lila Lee, Theodore Roberts, Harrison Ford, Guy Oliver | score |
| 28 . | The King's Pirate (1967) | Doug McClure, Jill St. John, Guy Stockwell, Mary Ann Mobley | score |
| 29 . | Pirate Gold (1913) | Blanche Sweet, Charles Hill Mailes, Hector Sarno, W. Chrystie Miller | score |
This chart uses a weighted rating based on the average rating per film and the number of votes per film.
