Film Noir Review : The Hoodlum (1951)

“You cheap hood. Always looking for a fall guy and never realizing you’re it.”

Madeleine L’Engle once wrote: “You have to know the darkness before you can appreciate the light.” Granted, L’Engle was speaking to humanity as a whole, but I’ve always found her words to ring particularly true when applied to film noir in particular. There’s a flicker of hope in the fulcrum of most noir, a dangling carrot for characters to pursue despite their impossible odds. Without it, they’d be deprived of the very thing that gives them purpose.

There are, of course, exceptions– the ones that not only spit in the face of this sentiment, but snuff it out and bury its remains somewhere in the woods. A less common breed, these films noir scoff at the possibility of hope — and by default, commercial appeal — for a dive into the trash heap of humanity. For them, the darkness is the only logical destination. This is where The Hoodlum fits in. Released by Monogram Pictures in 1951, it is a cheap, rotten little film that revels in its cheap and rotten world.

The Hoodlum 1951, So shocking you can't believe it!

The Hoodlum “So shocking you can’t believe it!”

Lawrence Tierney stars as Vincent Lubeck, a lifelong criminal who’s out on parole thanks to his mother (Lisa Golm). Though Lubeck has a rap sheet a mile long, she somehow and sells the parole board on giving him a second chance– only Lt. Burdick (Stuart Randall) is leery. Vincent returns home, and gets a job at the filling station owned by his straight-laced little brother Johnny (Edward Tierney). He and his wife Rosa (Allene Roberts) welcome Vincent with open arms, though it’s readily apparent that the compassion is not mutual, and before you can say reformed, Vincent is plotting to steal his brother’s business, his father’s inheritance money, and Rosa’s affection.

Why? Well, why not? He’s a hoodlum.

There’s an obsession with trash, both literally and metaphorically, that runs through Vincent’s story. In the opening scene, the faint flicker of the city dump can be seen through the windshield of Vincent and Johnny’s jalopy. In another, Vincent’s mother mentions that their new home is much nicer than the one they used to have by the city dump. “You can breath the air now,” she adds. To her, it is a matter of geography, but to Vincent, who’s visibly irritated by the discussion, it signifies something much more:

“Stop it, Ma! Keep the windows closed? What was the use? The stink came through them anyhow into all the corners of your lungs, your skin! Even if you took a bath every day, the stink would still stink! Our playground, where we picked up a few pieces of junk to get spending money. A rotten stink! Even now we’re not too far away from it! Yeah, but you wait! I’ve got ideas. I’ll get plenty of money! Yeah, dough! That’s the only thing that’ll ever cover up the stink of the city dump!”

The Hoodlum 1951, I haven't got far to go. When you die, you're a long time dead.

“I haven’t got far to go. When you die, you’re a long time dead.”

It’s one of the few times Vincent breaks his icy demeanor (one the notoriously tough Tierney was born to play), and it’s telling peek at his motivations. Every plan, every scheme, is a step closer to ridding himself of this stink. The wording here is especially interesting: Vincent doesn’t care to wash the smell away, but rather to cover it up, to spray the cologne of cash over it in the hopes that the world won’t notice. Even at his most ambitious, he’s limited by his impoverished perspective.

That being said, there’s absolutely no limit to what he will do will to succeed, whether it be his flirtation with Rosa or his plan to rob the bank across from the filling station. Director Max Nosseck doesn’t bother with motive, leaving these schemes as juvenile and callous as Vincent’s demeanor. He wants, but only so that he can take away from those around him. Upon winning Rosa’s affection — through implied sexual assault, no less — he decides he’s no longer interested, and casts her aside.

Nossek uses a sharp lighting trick in the scene where Rosa reveals that she’s become pregnant with Vincent’s child. He’s perched in the dark of the filling station alleyway and she stands, angelically, in front of the porch light. As the two become physical, and Vincent rejects her, they switch positions, and Rosa finds herself engulfed in the darkness, literally pushed out of the light by her corrupt brother-in-law. This visual flourish, one of the film’s few, takes on a grimmer connotation when Rosa later commits suicide by jumping off the roof.

The Hoodlum, 1951 The volatile relationship between Vincent and his brother Johnny.

The volatile relationship between Vincent (R) and his brother Johnny (L).

Vincent’s indifference towards her death — and that of his own child — is where the film far exceeds the cruelty of the era’s other noir. “Why did she do it?” Johnny murmurs over dinner, visibly shaken. “Because she was nuts,” snaps Vincent, “Any dame who would jump off a roof must be nuts.” Johnny moves to slug him, but Vincent doesn’t even flinch. As far as he’s concerned, all he did was prove Rosa a tramp, and anyone who loves a woman like that — i.e. Johnny — is a sucker. This brazen exchange would spark controversy today, let alone for an audience that was still uncomfortable seeing married couples sleep in the same bed. For me, the bleakness of the scene is topped only by my amazement at how Nossek and screenwriter Sam Neuman managed to get it by the censors.

Amidst the Shakespearean-level tragedy, Nossek makes the bank heist little more than an afterthought — an excuse for Vincent to incur even more destruction. So prominent is this, in fact, that when the heist goes sour, and police are called, we never see or hear from the rest of Vincent’s crew again. Instead, we follow a battered Vincent to his mother’s house, where she lays dying, presumably of a broken heart. She condemns her boy with a final, regretful breath.

The Hoodlum, 1951 It's too late Vincent. What can momma do? Go to the electric chair for you?

“It’s too late Vincent. What can momma do? Go to the electric chair for you?”

Johnny, the last surviving Lubeck, shows up to avenge her: “Nothing could stop her from loving you but death,” he mutters, holding a gun, “Well, now she’s dead, and you killed her. Just like you killed Papa and Rosa. We’re going on a little ride, to the city dump. I’m gonna finish all this where it started.”

We then return to the opening credits, where it’s revealed that Johnny is taking Vincent– quite literally– for a ride. He forces him out at a nearby ash pile, where he plans to do away with him. He’s ultimately unable to pull the trigger, overcome by his conscience, but Lt. Burdick, who’s been in pursuit since the heist, has no such reservations and plugs Vincent point blank. His limp body falls, scattered amidst the trash he tried so hard to escape. The smell is at last covered up, though it is chill of death, and not cash, that does the trick.

The Hoodlum, 1951, Lawrence Tierney's little brother, Edward, made his film debut as his onscreen brother.

Johnny Lubeck was played by Lawrence Tierney’s real-life brother, Edward, in his film debut.

With the exception of Abel Ferrara’s Bad Lieutenant (1992), it’s hard to imagine a more bleak, unrelenting film noir that The Hoodlum. For even in its devastation, Lieutenant had some semblance of morality — a light of hope, whether or not it was a drug-fueled mirage. The Hoodlum is soberly defiant up to its final breath, and embraces the darkness with open arms.

It’s disturbing journey not only in its content, but also in how little it cares about its characters. Vincent’s mother is shown the error of her ways in her fleeting moments. Rosa is corrupted and shamed into suicide while carrying a child. And Johnny, in the film’s cruelest instance, is left alive to mourn them all. All victims of The Hoodlum. All witnesses to what humanity can be when it never leaves the trash heap.

An essential, undervalued viewing for those with a penchant for nihilism and the nastier side of 1950s noir. A

TRIVIA: The film was restored from its original camera negative and screened at the UCLA Festival of Film Preservation in 2009.


–Danilo Castro for Classic Movie Hub

Danilo Castro is a film noir enthusiast and Contributing Writer for Classic Movie Hub. You can read more of Danilo’s articles and reviews at the Film Noir Archive, or you can follow Danilo on Twitter @DaniloSCastro.

This entry was posted in Posts by Danilo Castro and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Film Noir Review : The Hoodlum (1951)

  1. Probably going to need a strong dose of Lassie Come Home after watching this one.

  2. Shelia says:

    Great review!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>